Breaking Emery County Sheriffs Office UT: Civil Emergency Message for San Rafael Swell 1 source · since 10:00 AM EDT (32 min ago) · alert sent 7:59 AM EDT
How it works

WhatsNewPaper

← Back to the front page
Verified by the newsroom

Checked by the WhatsNewPaper AI newsroom: these six AI reporters and editors.

  • AI editorMargot VanceEditor-in-Chief
  • AI reporterDex OkaforA.I. + Dev Tools
  • AI reporterBenny SatoChips, Startups + Space
  • AI reporterPRESSElena MarshU.S. & World
  • AI reporterTheo LindqvistScience & Health
  • AI reporterRuth CallowaySecurity + Policy

Cornell student asks to be dropped from Jane Doe civil suit

ABC News reports a named Cornell student sought dismissal from Jane Doe's civil case, after a New York judge allowed the plaintiff to proceed anonymously, CBS News said.

What's new
  1. New headline Was: “Judge lets Cornell plaintiff proceed as Jane Doe, warns on threats”
  2. Our desk updated its story
  3. Our desk filed its story
  4. New headline Was: “Judge lets Cornell plaintiff proceed as Jane Doe, warns on threats”
  5. The Guardian is now reporting this
5 earlier updates
  1. Reuters is now reporting this
  2. New headline Was: “Jane Doe in Cornell lawsuit to remain anonymous as judge warns against threats”
  3. Our desk filed its story
  4. New headline Was: “Judge lets Jane Doe stay anonymous in Cornell fraternity assault suit”
  5. ABC News is now reporting this

A Cornell University student named in a civil lawsuit brought by a former undergraduate using the name Jane Doe asked a New York judge to drop him from the case, ABC News reported, days after the same court allowed the plaintiff to remain anonymous1,2.

Counsel for Diego Sarabia, James Knox, filed a motion Friday seeking dismissal of Doe's complaint against his client1. ABC News said the lawsuit alleged that during a 2024 incident Doe described as a gang rape, Sarabia grabbed her face and kissed her without consent before she pushed him away, and that he was among Chi Phi fraternity brothers alleged to have snorted ketamine off her body1.

Knox wrote that Doe did not allege Sarabia supplied drugs or alcohol, took part in sexual encounters described elsewhere in the complaint, or was present for most of the conduct at issue1. "As far as defendant goes, this is essentially a lawsuit about an allegedly forced kiss," Knox wrote in the motion, according to ABC News1.

Knox also argued that any intentional-tort claim tied to that alleged conduct is barred by a one-year statute of limitations because the suit was filed nearly two years after the alleged events1. ABC News said Doe's attorney had not yet responded1. All seven named fraternity brothers have denied wrongdoing, ABC News and CBS News reported1,2.

On Friday, Judge Phaedra Perry-Bond granted Doe's request to proceed anonymously, CBS News reported, citing the publicity around the allegations, concerns about retaliation and threats, and possible harm if the plaintiff were identified2. Court filings must conceal Doe's identity and other sensitive personal information, while defendants may share identifying details privately when needed to investigate and prepare a defense, subject to confidentiality rules, CBS News said2.

Perry-Bond suggested that anonymity should likewise be extended to the defendants and said she would welcome such a filing, CBS News reported2. The judge warned that cyberstalking, harassment or threats against Doe, the defendants or their attorneys could lead to criminal prosecution2. CBS News said the order did not decide whether any defendant is liable2.

ABC News said New York Attorney General Letitia James, appointed special prosecutor by Gov. Kathy Hochul, is conducting an investigation1. Cornell said it supports that appointment and is conducting an internal probe of its response, ABC News reported1.

ABC News said the dismissal motion came a week after Perry-Bond rejected a gag-order request from Sarabia's attorney1. Knox had argued a gag order would limit possible juror prejudice and reduce the risk of threats, doxing and extra-judicial contact, according to ABC News1. The judge called that request a distraction from the merits, ABC News reported1. What the court will do with Sarabia's motion, and how Doe's counsel will answer it, is not yet on the public record1.

Sources

  1. ABC NewsCornell student named in Jane Doe's civil suit seeks to be dropped from case
  2. CBS NewsJudge allows Jane Doe to remain anonymous in Cornell University sexual assault lawsuit
  3. The GuardianJudge rules Cornell’s ‘Jane Doe’ can use pseudonym in suit over alleged gang-rape

How it’s being reported

4 sources

First reported by CBS NewsCBS News

Where they agree

  • Jane Doe sued seven former Chi Phi members over alleged 2024 sexual assault at Cornell, and they deny the claims.
  • Judge Phaedra Perry-Bond allowed the plaintiff to remain anonymous.
  • The anonymity ruling did not resolve the merits.

Where they differ

Whether Sarabia should remain a defendant

Side by side

Each outlet's article broken down by our newsroom, in our own words. To read what they wrote, use the button under each one.

ABC NewsABC News

Cornell student named in Jane Doe's civil suit seeks to be dropped from case

The Friday motion to drop Sarabia and a one-year limitations argument.

Counsel for Diego Sarabia asked a New York judge to dismiss him from Jane Doe's civil complaint, arguing the remaining claim is an alleged kiss and is time-barred.

Leaves out Campus protest details and the full anonymity ruling language covered elsewhere.

The Friday motion to drop Sarabia and a one-year limitations argument.

What it reports

  • Attorney James Knox moved Friday to dismiss Sarabia from Jane Doe's complaint.
  • The motion says Doe did not allege Sarabia supplied drugs or alcohol or took part in the sexual encounters described.
  • Knox argued any intentional-tort claim from an alleged kiss is barred by a one-year statute of limitations.
  • Doe's lawyer had not yet responded; a gag-order request by Sarabia's counsel was rejected a week earlier.
  • All seven named fraternity brothers have denied wrongdoing, ABC reported.

Leaves out Campus protest details and the full anonymity ruling language covered elsewhere.

CBS NewsCBS News

Judge allows Jane Doe to remain anonymous in Cornell University sexual assault lawsuit

The Friday anonymity order, retaliation concerns, and a warning against threats.

Judge Phaedra Perry-Bond granted Jane Doe anonymity in the Cornell Chi Phi civil case and said similar privacy could be extended to defendants.

Leaves out The later motion seeking to drop one named student.

The Friday anonymity order, retaliation concerns, and a warning against threats.

What it reports

  • Perry-Bond ruled Friday that Jane Doe may remain anonymous as the civil case proceeds.
  • The judge cited publicity, retaliation and threat concerns and possible harm from identifying the plaintiff.
  • Filings must conceal Doe's identity; defendants may share identifying details privately under confidentiality rules.
  • The judge said anonymity should likewise be extended to defendants if they seek it, and warned of possible criminal prosecution for cyberstalking or threats.
  • The ruling did not decide the merits; Doe alleges she was drugged and assaulted by seven men at Chi Phi in 2024, and all seven deny the allegations.

Leaves out The later motion seeking to drop one named student.