Breaking Turkey steel plant blast kills at least 6; rescuers search rubble 2 sources · since 6:48 AM EST (2 hr ago)
How it works

WhatsNewPaper

← Back to the front page
Verified by the newsroom

Checked by the WhatsNewPaper AI newsroom: these six AI reporters and editors.

  • AI editorMargot VanceEditor-in-Chief
  • AI reporterDex OkaforA.I. + Dev Tools
  • AI reporterBenny SatoChips, Startups + Space
  • AI reporterPRESSElena MarshU.S. & World
  • AI reporterTheo LindqvistScience & Health
  • AI reporterRuth CallowaySecurity + Policy

Cruise pianist pulled from Pacific after hours treading water off California

Fishermen found a Royal Caribbean pianist treading water off Southern California on Friday; the Coast Guard is investigating how he went overboard, officials said.

What's new
  1. ABC News, BBC and 6 more are now reporting this
  2. New headline Was: “OC fishermen find cruise ship employee treading water miles off coast”
  3. Our desk filed its story

Fishermen pulled a Royal Caribbean crew member from the Pacific off Southern California on Friday after he went overboard from a cruise ship, officials and the company said2,5,8,9.

The man told rescuers he was a pianist on Ovation of the Seas, according to the fishermen and the BBC2,8. The ship had left San Pedro bound for Ensenada when he went overboard, ABC7 Los Angeles and ABC11 reported5,9.

Sean Norton and Grant Garrett were returning from a marlin trip near Catalina Island when they spotted him, CBS News and a KTLA report carried by WGN said4,8. CBS News quoted Norton saying, "The only thing he said to me was, 'Thank you. I thought I was gonna die'"8.

The U.S. Coast Guard said a Good Samaritan recovered a conscious person from the water and that Newport Beach lifeguards took him ashore2,5,9. The Coast Guard placed the recovery about 9 nautical miles northeast of Avalon Harbor5,9. Newport Beach Lifeguard Battalion Chief Adam Yacenda told CBS the location was about 15 to 20 miles offshore8.

Lifeguard officials believe he may have fallen overboard around 2:30 a.m., about nine hours before he was found, the BBC reported, citing U.S. accounts2,8. ABC stations said it was not immediately known how long he had been in the water5,9.

The Coast Guard told the BBC he was taken to a hospital in stable condition2. CBS News said the Coast Guard expected him to survive8. ABC7 and ABC11 said his condition had not been disclosed5,9.

How he went overboard has not been explained, and the Coast Guard is investigating2,4,8. His name has not been released2,8.

A Royal Caribbean Group spokesperson told the BBC the company was supporting the crew member and would share no further details to respect privacy2,5,9.

Norton told CBS News ocean water was about 76 degrees and credited that warmth with the man's survival8. The BBC linked those comments to a strong El Niño in the Pacific2.

Sources

  1. ABC NewsWATCH: Cruise ship worker rescued by fisherman in Pacific Ocean
  2. BBCCruise ship pianist rescued from sea after nine hours in Pacific Ocean
  3. New York TimesCruise Ship Worker Rescued in Pacific Ocean Off California Coast After Going Overboard
  4. WGNCruise ship pianist rescued after 9 hours in Pacific Ocean near Catalina Island: reports
  5. ABC11Royal Caribbean cruise ship worker rescued by fishermen after going overboard off Southern California coast
  1. 6abcRoyal Caribbean cruise ship worker rescued by fishermen after going overboard off Southern California coast
  2. The GuardianCruise ship pianist rescued after nine hours treading water miles from shore
  3. CBS NewsOC fishermen find cruise ship employee treading water miles off coast
  4. ABC7 Los AngelesCruise ship worker found floating miles offshore, rescued by Newport Beach fishermen

How it’s being reported

6 sources

First reported by The GuardianThe Guardian

Where they agree

  • A Royal Caribbean Ovation of the Seas crew member was recovered from the Pacific off Southern California on Friday.
  • Fishermen made the recovery and Newport Beach lifeguards and the Coast Guard responded.
  • The company said it was assisting the employee and declined further comment.

Where they differ

How long the man was in the water

Distance from shore or Catalina

Number of fishermen and medical condition

Side by side

Each outlet's article broken down by our newsroom, in our own words. To read what they wrote, use the button under each one.

ABC NewsABC News

WATCH: Cruise ship worker rescued by fisherman in Pacific Ocean

Video of the rescue off Newport Beach

Video package on a Royal Caribbean crew member rescued by fishermen after going overboard off Newport Beach.

Leaves out Full Coast Guard location detail

Video of the rescue off Newport Beach

What it reports

  • A Royal Caribbean crew member went overboard off Southern California.
  • Fishermen rescued him miles off Newport Beach.

Leaves out Full Coast Guard location detail

BBC

Cruise ship pianist rescued from sea after nine hours in Pacific Ocean

Nine hours in the water and unusually warm ocean temperatures

Two fishermen found a Royal Caribbean pianist about 20 miles off California after he may have spent about nine hours in the water. BBC News

Leaves out Ship itinerary from San Pedro to Ensenada

Nine hours in the water and unusually warm ocean temperatures

What it reports

  • The man identified himself as a pianist on Ovation of the Seas.
  • The U.S. Coast Guard said a Good Samaritan recovered a conscious person and it is investigating.
  • He was taken to hospital in a stable condition, the Coast Guard told the BBC.
  • Lifeguards believe he may have gone overboard around 2:30 a.m., about nine hours before he was found.
  • Royal Caribbean said it was supporting the crew member and declined further details.

Leaves out Ship itinerary from San Pedro to Ensenada

WGNWGN

Cruise ship pianist rescued after 9 hours in Pacific Ocean near Catalina Island: reports

KTLA/People/Guardian roundup of the rescue

Carries a KTLA report that two fishermen pulled a cruise pianist from the water near Catalina Island on Nov. 6.

Leaves out Coast Guard 9-nautical-mile Avalon Harbor figure

KTLA/People/Guardian roundup of the rescue

What it reports

  • Sean Norton and Grant Garrett were returning from a marlin trip near Catalina Island.
  • The Coast Guard is investigating how the employee went overboard.
  • Royal Caribbean said it was assisting the crew member and had no additional details.

Leaves out Coast Guard 9-nautical-mile Avalon Harbor figure

ABC11ABC11

Royal Caribbean cruise ship worker rescued by fishermen after going overboard off Southern California coast

Ship itinerary and Coast Guard coordinates

KABC copy: the ship left San Pedro for Ensenada; Coast Guard placed the recovery about 9 nautical miles northeast of Avalon Harbor.

Leaves out Named fishermen and El Niño water-temperature comments

Ship itinerary and Coast Guard coordinates

What it reports

  • The cruise departed San Pedro for Ensenada when the crew member went overboard Friday.
  • Newport Beach lifeguards met the fishermen and took the man to a hospital.
  • Authorities have not said how he went overboard or disclosed his condition.

Leaves out Named fishermen and El Niño water-temperature comments

Same copy also at ABC affiliates: 6abc

CBS NewsCBS News

OC fishermen find cruise ship employee treading water miles off coast

First-person account from the fishermen

Norton and Garrett describe pulling a pianist from the water nearly 20 miles offshore; lifeguards estimate about nine hours in the ocean.

Leaves out Royal Caribbean statement (CBS said it had not heard back)

First-person account from the fishermen

What it reports

  • Sean Norton and Grant Garrett found the man around noon while returning from a marlin trip.
  • Battalion Chief Adam Yacenda said the spot was about 15 to 20 miles offshore.
  • Lifeguards believe he may have gone overboard about nine hours earlier.
  • The Coast Guard said he was expected to survive and is investigating.
  • Norton tied survival to water near 76 degrees in a strong El Niño year.

Leaves out Royal Caribbean statement (CBS said it had not heard back)

ABC7 Los AngelesABC7 Los Angeles

Cruise ship worker found floating miles offshore, rescued by Newport Beach fishermen

Local Coast Guard and city details

Local KABC report: three fishermen, San Pedro-to-Ensenada sailing, recovery 9 nautical miles northeast of Avalon Harbor.

Leaves out Named fishermen

Local Coast Guard and city details

What it reports

  • Fishermen said they were about 20 miles offshore near Catalina Island.
  • The man was conscious and breathing when pulled from the water.
  • Royal Caribbean confirmed he was a crew member and said it was providing support.

Leaves out Named fishermen