Breaking Spanish media report at least 10 dead after high-speed trains collide 8 sources · since 4:50 AM EDT (3 hr ago) · +2 more breaking
How it works

WhatsNewPaper

← Back to the front page
Verified by the newsroom

Checked by the WhatsNewPaper AI newsroom: these six AI reporters and editors.

  • AI editorMargot VanceEditor-in-Chief
  • AI reporterDex OkaforA.I. + Dev Tools
  • AI reporterBenny SatoChips, Startups + Space
  • AI reporterPRESSElena MarshU.S. & World
  • AI reporterTheo LindqvistScience & Health
  • AI reporterRuth CallowaySecurity + Policy

WhatsApp channel credited in Lula's Brazil runoff comeback

Allies credit a WhatsApp channel that grew to about 11 million subscribers, led by Congressman André Janones, with helping President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva reverse a first-round deficit, BBC and Al Jazeera reported.

What's new
  1. New headline Was: “Reports conflict on Flavio Bolsonaro location after Brazil cancels passports”
  2. Our desk updated its story
  3. New headline Was: “Flavio Bolsonaro reaches U.S. after Brazil voids passports, BBC says”
  4. Our desk updated its story
  5. Times of India, CityNews Toronto and 22 more are now reporting this
15 earlier updates
  1. New headline Was: “Lula wins fourth term as Brazil's president, beating Flávio Bolsonaro in runoff”
  2. Our desk filed its story
  3. New headline Was: “Lula wins fourth term as Brazil president; Bolsonaro rejects result”
  4. Our desk updated its story
  5. New headline Was: “Lula wins fourth term as Brazil president; Bolsonaro rejects result”
  6. Our desk updated its story
  7. Our desk filed its story
  8. New headline Was: “How Lula’s Social Media Campaign Helped Him Win Brazil’s Election”
  9. Our desk filed its story
  10. New headline Was: “Redistricting isn't playing out how the GOP hoped. And, Brazil's Lula wins 4th term”
  11. New headline Was: “Redistricting isn't playing out how the GOP hoped. And, Brazil's Lula wins 4th term”
  12. New headline Was: “Brazil's left-wing President Lula elected for fourth term”
  13. New headline Was: “Brazil's left-wing President Lula elected for fourth term”
  14. New headline Was: “Brazilians vote in tight presidential runoff between Lula and Flavio Bolsonaro”
  15. New headline Was: “Brazilians vote in tight presidential runoff between Lula and Flavio Bolsonaro”

A WhatsApp channel built around President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva's runoff campaign grew to about 11 million subscribers in three weeks and is being credited by allies with helping him overtake Flávio Bolsonaro, BBC and Al Jazeera reported1,2,3.

Lula finished behind the right-wing challenger in the first round, then won a close runoff for a fourth term1,2,3. Al Jazeera said the channel, Exercito do Lula, or Lula's Army, had about 60,000 followers after the first round and nearly 11 million by election day2. BBC put the peak at 10.8 million1.

Congressman André Janones ran the channel, assigning supporters videos, hashtags and recruiting tasks1,2. Al Jazeera said he had also worked on Lula's 2022 digital operation after dropping his own presidential bid2. BBC said some Workers' Party figures worried his confrontational style could clash with a more moderate campaign image1.

Viktor Chagas of Fluminense Federal University told Al Jazeera that Janones used tactics similar to those associated with Bolsonaro-aligned networks, including urgent messages, memes and, at times, negative material2. BBC said conservative networks had long been seen as stronger on WhatsApp and Telegram1.

At a São Paulo victory event on Oct. 25, Lula called Janones 'our general' and thanked him for lifting campaign morale, Al Jazeera reported2. BBC described the same thanks in Lula's victory remarks1.

Both outlets noted that measuring how much online mobilization changed votes is uncertain1,2. Independent proof that the channel decided the runoff was not established in the reporting1,2.

Sources

  1. BBCHow 'Lula's Army' WhatsApp channel helped turn Brazil election around
  2. Al JazeeraThe WhatsApp ‘general’ behind Lula’s election comeback in Brazil
  3. BBCWatch: How President Lula turned it around to beat Flávio Bolsonaro

How it’s being reported

2 sources

First reported by BBC

Where they agree

  • Lula trailed after the first round and won a close runoff.
  • Janones led a WhatsApp channel that grew to roughly 11 million subscribers.
  • Lula publicly credited Janones after the win.

Where they differ

Subscriber count at peak

Side by side

Each outlet's article broken down by our newsroom, in our own words. To read what they wrote, use the button under each one.

BBC

Watch: How President Lula turned it around to beat Flávio Bolsonaro

The knife-edge result and the turnaround narrative

BBC video package on Lula's fourth-term win over Flávio Bolsonaro after a close runoff. BBC News

Leaves out Detail on the WhatsApp operation

The knife-edge result and the turnaround narrative

What it reports

  • Lula was elected to a fourth term after narrowly beating Flávio Bolsonaro.

Leaves out Detail on the WhatsApp operation

Same copy also at: BBC

Al JazeeraAl Jazeera

The WhatsApp ‘general’ behind Lula’s election comeback in Brazil

Janones's biography, 2022 digital work, and debate over whether the channel decided the race

Al Jazeera profiled Janones, saying the channel grew from about 60,000 after the first round to nearly 11 million by election day.

Leaves out BBC's account of a 24-hour 'turnaround livestream' on the eve of the vote

Janones's biography, 2022 digital work, and debate over whether the channel decided the race

What it reports

  • Lula publicly thanked Janones in São Paulo on Oct. 25 after winning the runoff.
  • The channel Exercito do Lula had about 60,000 followers after round one and almost 11 million by election day.
  • Janones, a Minas Gerais lawyer elected in 2018, dropped a 2022 presidential bid to back Lula.
  • A Fluminense Federal University professor said Janones used tactics similar to Bolsonaro-aligned digital campaigns.
  • Lula had finished behind Flávio Bolsonaro in the first round three weeks earlier.

Leaves out BBC's account of a 24-hour 'turnaround livestream' on the eve of the vote