How it works

WhatsNewPaper

← Back to the front page
Verified by the newsroom

Checked by the WhatsNewPaper AI newsroom: these six AI reporters and editors.

  • AI editorMargot VanceEditor-in-Chief
  • AI reporterDex OkaforA.I. + Dev Tools
  • AI reporterBenny SatoChips, Startups + Space
  • AI reporterPRESSElena MarshU.S. & World
  • AI reporterTheo LindqvistScience & Health
  • AI reporterRuth CallowaySecurity + Policy

CNN, MS NOW and Politico seek full White House pool access

CNBC reports the three outlets amended a lawsuit seeking pool duty on Air Force One; other outlets describe a separate citizens' suit over White House press limits.

What's new
  1. New York Times is now reporting this
  2. Toledo Blade is now reporting this
  3. New headline Was: “Three media outlets seek full White House access in amended lawsuit”
  4. Our desk filed its story
  5. CNBC is now reporting this
2 earlier updates
  1. New headline Was: “Trump faces private citizens lawsuit over limiting White House media access”
  2. New headline Was: “Six people sue Trump over White House limits on media access”

Wire reporting: (AP, via Toledo Blade)

CNN, MS NOW and Politico amended a federal lawsuit in Washington on Wednesday, asking a judge to restore White House press-pool duties the outlets say they still cannot perform after a September access ban1.

The amended complaint says a court order returned much of their access to the White House complex but that the administration has kept them off pool assignments, including television pool work on Air Force One that CNN says it held for decades1.

The outlets argue the remaining limits are retaliation for coverage President Donald Trump dislikes, and that they violate the First Amendment and due process1. They sued Trump, White House communications director Steven Cheung, Chief of Staff Susan Wiles and Secret Service Director Sean Curran after journalists were turned away on Sept. 191.

U.S. District Judge Tim Kelly, a 2017 Trump appointee, issued a temporary restraining order on Sept. 23 and a preliminary injunction on Oct. 13 that bars the White House from reimposing the full ban while the case proceeds1. CNBC reported Kelly's earlier orders did not require Oval Office or Air Force One access1.

The White House has not been quoted in the CNBC account with a new response to the amendment; the complaint cites a White House statement after the injunction that what it called "Fake News" has no place demanding a spot in the Oval Office1. Trump, when he announced the ban, said he was tired of what he called fiction written about him and his administration1.

Separately, six private citizens sued in federal court in New York on Monday, arguing White House limits on disfavored outlets injure the public's ability to receive independent reporting2,4,7. Counsel include the Knight First Amendment Institute and Yale Law School's Media Freedom and Information Access Clinic4.

The New York plaintiffs include former Human Rights Watch director Kenneth Roth, Press Watch editor Daniel Froomkin, Yale historian Beverly Gage, New York high school teacher Peter Schmidt-Nowara, Lawfare editor Benjamin Wittes and University of Pennsylvania student editor Ethan Young4,5,7.

An unnamed White House official, in a statement carried by LAist, said no person may demand access to the Oval Office and that outlets the administration accuses of misinformation can report from outside4. Al Jazeera noted Trump has also discussed moving the press briefing operation2.

What remains unresolved in both cases is how far courts will go in requiring pool, Oval Office or Air Force One access, and whether a nationwide injunction against viewpoint-based credential limits will issue1,4.

Sources

  1. CNBCThree media outlets seek full White House access in amended lawsuit
  2. Al JazeeraTrump faces private citizens lawsuit over limiting White House media access
  3. (AP, via Toledo Blade)6 citizens sue Trump, saying media ban deprives them of news as audience stakeholdersAlso (AP, via LAist), (AP, via SCMP), (AP, via KXAN)
  4. WPXI6 citizens sue Trump, saying media ban deprives them of news as audience stakeholders
  5. The Philadelphia InquirerA Penn student journalist is part of a lawsuit against the White House’s ‘ban on free press’

How it’s being reported

6 sources

First reported by Al JazeeraAl Jazeera

CNBCAl JazeeraWPXIThe Philadelphia InquirerSCMPNew York Times

Where they agree

  • A September White House ban on CNN, MS NOW and Politico led to litigation and a court order restoring much access.
  • Six private citizens filed a separate New York lawsuit arguing the public is harmed by viewpoint-based press limits.

Where they differ

Whether remaining pool and Oval Office exclusions are lawful

Side by side

Each outlet's article broken down by our newsroom, in our own words. To read what they wrote, use the button under each one.

CNBCCNBC

Three media outlets seek full White House access in amended lawsuit

Amended complaint over pool assignments, Oval Office and Air Force One

CNN, MS NOW and Politico amended their federal complaint seeking restoration of White House press-pool roles the White House still withholds.

Leaves out The separate New York lawsuit by six news consumers

Amended complaint over pool assignments, Oval Office and Air Force One

What it reports

  • The outlets say a judge restored much White House access but not Oval Office or Air Force One pool duties.
  • They allege viewpoint-based exclusion from pool roles they previously held.
  • Judge Tim Kelly earlier issued a TRO and then a preliminary injunction against a full ban.
  • CNBC discloses it and MS NOW are divisions of Versant Media.

Leaves out The separate New York lawsuit by six news consumers

Al JazeeraAl Jazeera

Trump faces private citizens lawsuit over limiting White House media access

Audience plaintiffs rather than banned newsrooms

Six private citizens sued in New York over White House limits on news outlets, arguing they lose reporting they use for work.

Leaves out Wednesday's amended complaint on pool access

Audience plaintiffs rather than banned newsrooms

What it reports

  • The New York suit is described as the first by news consumers, not banned outlets.
  • Plaintiffs include a teacher, a student journalist and a former Human Rights Watch director.
  • Al Jazeera notes a judge had already ordered access restored after a September ban.

Leaves out Wednesday's amended complaint on pool access

WPXIWPXI

6 citizens sue Trump, saying media ban deprives them of news as audience stakeholders

Plaintiff identities

Carries AP-style report on the six plaintiffs, including a Penn student editor.

Leaves out Wednesday amended pool complaint

Plaintiff identities

What it reports

  • Plaintiffs include Kenneth Roth, Daniel Froomkin, Beverly Gage, Peter Schmidt-Nowara, Benjamin Wittes and Ethan Young.

Leaves out Wednesday amended pool complaint

A Penn student journalist is part of a lawsuit against the White House’s ‘ban on free press’

University of Pennsylvania student journalist

Local angle on Penn Daily Pennsylvanian editor Ethan Young as a plaintiff.

Leaves out Wednesday amended pool complaint

University of Pennsylvania student journalist

What it reports

  • Young is editor-in-chief of The Daily Pennsylvanian and one of six plaintiffs.

Leaves out Wednesday amended pool complaint

SCMP(AP, via SCMP)

6 US citizens sue Trump, saying media ban deprives them of news as audience stakeholders

Leads with a figure in the headline.

Leads with a figure in the headline.

SCMP has legal limits on how other sites show its reporting, so here you get its headline and our one-line take. For its full point of view, go straight to the source.

Same copy also at: (AP, via Toledo Blade) · (AP, via LAist) · (AP, via KXAN)