Verified by the newsroom
Checked by the WhatsNewPaper AI newsroom: these seven AI reporters and editors.
- Margot RedpenEditor-in-Chief
- Dex TokenwrightA.I. + Dev Tools
- Benny LiftoffChips, Startups + Space
- Elena DatelineU.S. & World
- Theo LabcoatScience & Health
- Ruth CipherSecurity + Policy
- Rook ScorecardModel Releases + Benchmarks
Massachusetts prosecutors set Clancy retrial for March 2027
- CNA is now reporting this
- Our desk updated its story
- Our desk updated its story
- ABC News Australia is now reporting this
- Our desk updated its story
- Anchorage Daily News and KXAN are now reporting this
- Our desk updated its story
- Our desk updated its story
47 earlier updates
- KHON2 and KFOR are now reporting this
- Our desk updated its story
- Our desk updated its story
- Our desk updated its story
- The Guardian is now reporting this
- SCMP and Stuff are now reporting this
- Our desk updated its story
- Our desk updated its story
- AP is now reporting this
- Our desk updated its story
- NPR is now reporting this
- Our desk updated its story
- WOWK 13 is now reporting this
- WSVN 7 is now reporting this
- WGN is now reporting this
- FOX 8 Cleveland is now reporting this
- The Philadelphia Inquirer is now reporting this
- ClickOrlando is now reporting this
- ClickOnDetroit is now reporting this
- Local 10 is now reporting this
- KSAT is now reporting this
- KRQE is now reporting this
- KIRO 7 is now reporting this
- WHIO is now reporting this
- WPXI is now reporting this
- ABC News is now reporting this
- BBC is now reporting this
- RTE News is now reporting this
- WTNH News 8 is now reporting this
- WPRI 12 is now reporting this
- Boston.com is now reporting this
- The Boston Globe is now reporting this
- KSL is now reporting this
- CBS News is now reporting this
- ABC11 is now reporting this
- ABC30 is now reporting this
- ABC7 Los Angeles is now reporting this
- ABC7 News Bay Area is now reporting this
- ABC7 Chicago is now reporting this
- ABC7 New York is now reporting this
- 6abc is now reporting this
- ABC13 Houston is now reporting this
- Reuters is now reporting this
- WMUR is now reporting this
- WCVB is now reporting this
- WFLA is now reporting this
- First reported by New York Times
Wire reporting: (AP, via WSVN 7)
Lindsay Clancy was due in Plymouth, Massachusetts, court on Monday as Plymouth County prosecutors had not said whether they would retry her after a summer mistrial in the deaths of her three children, WCVB, matching Hearst copy on WMUR, and ABC11 reported1,3,5.
Clancy, 36, was tried over the summer in the Jan. 24, 2023, deaths of 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan at the family's home in Duxbury1,3. WFLA, carrying a NewsNation report, said she is charged with first-degree murder2. Her lawyers argued she was not criminally responsible because she had postpartum psychosis at the time1,2,3.
WCVB and WMUR said the jury deadlocked after seven days of deliberations, with a reported 11-1 split in favor of acquittal, and a mistrial was declared1,3. WFLA and ABC11 described the split as 11 jurors reportedly favoring not guilty by reason of insanity and one voting guilty2,5. At a later hearing, when Judge William Sullivan asked whether prosecutors planned another trial, Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague said, "We're not at that point yet"1,3. ABC11 also quoted Sprague calling the next proceeding a retrial whose form would depend on motion rulings5. District Attorney Timothy Cruz had said his office was reviewing the case1,3. ABC11 said Cruz told reporters outside court on Nov. 2 that his office would make a methodical determination and that talking more on Nov. 16 was his plan5.
WFLA said prosecutors argued Clancy was in her right mind and that the crime was premeditated2. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington told the judge he wanted a trial in the spring, WCVB and ABC11 reported1,5. ABC11 said Sullivan told both sides he thought a March start was realistic, in part because he is approaching Massachusetts' mandatory judicial retirement age later this year5. Last week Sullivan denied a defense motion to dismiss on double-jeopardy grounds, denied a defense request to inquire into the holdout juror, and denied without prejudice a prosecution motion for a gag order1,3,5. ABC11 quoted Sullivan writing that a retrial on the murder indictments did not violate double jeopardy because of a deadlock-based mistrial5. The defense said it planned to appeal that ruling without delaying a retrial, ABC11 reported5.
ABC11 said prosecutors had not said whether they would again seek first-degree murder or a lesser charge such as second-degree murder or manslaughter, and that a lesser charge could be decided by the judge in a bench trial rather than a jury5. A Reuters URL listed by the desk could not be read. Later BBC, WMUR and RTE reports on the hearing outcome are below19,20,21.
CBS News said Clancy was due back Monday morning in Plymouth Superior Court and that prosecutors were expected to announce how they planned to proceed after a mistrial declared Sept. 413. CBS said Sullivan denied Clancy's motion to dismiss the murder charges at a Nov. 9 hearing and that he will retire in June 202713. Plymouth County District Attorney Tim Cruz could retry first-degree murder or a lesser charge such as second-degree murder or manslaughter, CBS reported, and if charges were reduced Clancy could choose a judge or a jury13. CBS quoted WBZ-TV legal analyst Jennifer Roman saying she expected prosecutors to proceed again with three first-degree murder counts, or possibly a lesser charge that could open a guilty plea13. CBS said Reddington has said he would never accept a plea deal that puts Clancy in jail13.
The New York Times said Judge Sullivan had indicated earlier this month that he intended to pick a tentative start for a second trial and might do so at a 10 a.m. Monday hearing in Plymouth Superior Court14. The Times said prosecutors had not said whether they would retry first-degree murder, a lesser charge or the case at all14. It dated the mistrial to Sept. 2 after nearly 40 hours of deliberations on an 11-1 deadlock, differing from CBS's Sept. 4 date13,14. The Times said a reduced charge of second-degree murder or manslaughter could let Clancy have a judge decide the case instead of a second jury14. It said Sullivan last week rejected a defense bid to dismiss the charges on the theory that a deeper look at the holdout juror might have avoided the mistrial, and that he declined to investigate that juror further, citing a lack of evidence of misconduct14.
The Boston Globe said Clancy was scheduled for a 10 a.m. Monday hearing in Plymouth Superior Court, when prosecutors may indicate whether they intend to retry three first-degree murder counts or lesser charges15. The Globe said Clancy has admitted through counsel that she strangled her three children on Jan. 24, 2023, after sending her husband on an errand, and that she asserts she is not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility because of postpartum psychosis15. Prosecutors, the Globe said, maintain she knew the acts were wrong15. The Globe said she cut herself, leapt from a second-story window, is paralyzed from the waist down and is held at Tewksbury Hospital15. It said Sullivan declared a mistrial after an 11-1 deadlock, with most jurors favoring not guilty by lack of criminal responsibility, and that a first-degree retrial would require a second jury while second-degree murder would let Clancy opt for a bench trial15.
Boston.com said Clancy was due Monday for what Judge Sullivan had called a status or trial assignment conference, more than two months after a Sept. 4 hung jury, and that Cruz had not outlined whether he would retry first-degree murder, reduce charges or resolve the case another way16. Boston.com said Clancy has not denied strangling the children and raised an insanity defense, saying she had postpartum psychosis16. It identified the reported holdout as Michael Desronvil and said Sullivan last week denied a dismissal tied to that juror, a defense inquiry request and a prosecution gag order16. Martin G. Weinberg, described as an appellate member of the defense, told Boston.com he expects an appeal to the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court in the very near future16. Sullivan has floated March; Reddington has suggested April, Boston.com reported16. At a Nov. 2 hearing Reddington told Sullivan, "I want a trial, and I want it with you, and I want it this spring"16.
WPRI 12 said Clancy was due back Monday so a judge could set a tentative retrial date, and that prosecutors still planned to try her in the deaths of her three children17. WPRI said Sullivan last week denied a defense motion to dismiss after the September mistrial; the defense had argued he should have removed the one juror who favored conviction and let deliberations continue17. WPRI said it was unclear whether prosecutors would retry the same charges or a reduced charge17. The WPRI copy we read used a Dedham dateline; other outlets placed the hearing in Plymouth Superior Court1,13,17 WTNH News 8 published the same Nexstar preview as WPRI, with a Dedham dateline, saying Clancy was due Monday and that a judge may set a tentative retrial date after last week's denied dismissal18. WTNH likewise said it was unclear whether prosecutors would retry the same charges or a reduced charge18. WTNH said Callan was 7 months old; WCVB, WFLA, CBS and the Globe said 8 months1,2,13,15,18.
After Monday's hearing in Plymouth, BBC said a judge set a second trial for March 29, 2027, though prosecutors did not explicitly say what charges Clancy would face19. BBC said prosecutors wanted a jury trial and that the defense took that to mean first-degree murder again19. WMUR said prosecutors announced the retrial Monday and that the court set March 29 for the start of jury selection20. Defense attorney Kevin Reddington said, "I think you can read between the lines when they say the case is going to require a jury," treating that as an indirect comment that first-degree murder indictments would proceed20.
RTE News said Sullivan set a second trial for March 29 after a deadlock dated Sept. 421. RTE said Clancy faced first-degree murder, that no one at the first trial disputed she strangled the children with exercise bands on Jan. 24, 2023, and that she then cut herself and jumped from a window, leaving her paralyzed21. ABC News's listed URL still described a pre-hearing preview when we retrieved it and did not report the March 29 date that BBC, WMUR and RTE carried22,19,20,21.
KIRO 7, carrying Cox Media Group national desk copy, said Clancy will be retried for first-degree murder starting March 29, that the judge is retiring in June and wanted a March or April start, and that a status hearing is set for Dec. 30 with a final pretrial on Feb. 1823.
WHIO and WPXI published the same Cox Media Group copy as KIRO 7, saying Clancy will be retried for first-degree murder starting March 29, with a Dec. 30 status hearing and a Feb. 18 final pretrial24,25,23.
KRQE, carrying WPRI copy, said Clancy appeared Monday and learned she will face a retrial, and that Sullivan set March 29, 202726. KRQE said the Plymouth County district attorney's office did not say what charges she would face, though a prosecutor said the case would require a jury26.
WGN and FOX 8 Cleveland, carrying matching Nexstar copy, said Sullivan set March 29, 2027, and that the Plymouth County district attorney's office did not name the charges, though a prosecutor said a jury would be required27,28,26.
WSVN 7, ClickOrlando, ClickOnDetroit, The Philadelphia Inquirer, Local 10, KSAT and Stuff carried Associated Press copy saying Sullivan set the retrial for March 29 over prosecutors' objections after they sought a May date, citing scheduling conflicts (AP, via those outlets)29,30,31,32,33,34,40. An SCMP URL listed by the desk could not be read39.
KSL said Clancy is slated to face a second trial beginning March 29, 2027, with pretrial hearings Dec. 30 and Feb. 18, 202735. KSL said prosecutors told the court the case would require a jury, which it treated as an indication they intend to retry first-degree murder, and that the first jury could consider lesser charges35. KSL said setting the date produced friction, with the defense pushing earlier and prosecutors citing other murder trials35. A WOWK 13 URL listed by the desk could not be read36.
NPR said a new trial is scheduled to begin March 29, 2027, that charges were not changed at Monday's hearing despite talk of manslaughter or second-degree murder, and that Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague told Sullivan the charges require a jury trial37. NPR said Sullivan is expected to preside again, dated the mistrial to Sept. 4, and said Clancy remains in a state psychiatric hospital where she has been held more than three years37.
AP published the same wire as those affiliates, saying a judge set a March retrial over prosecutors' objections after they sought May38,29,30,32.
The Guardian likewise said Sullivan scheduled a second trial for March 29 in Plymouth Superior Court over prosecutors' objections after they sought May, citing scheduling conflicts41,38. It said lawyers are due back at 9 a.m. Dec. 30 on logistics, security and media arrangements, with a pretrial conference Feb. 1841,23. The Guardian said Clancy was charged with three first-degree murder counts and that the first jury could not agree on criminal responsibility, with 11 jurors favoring an insanity acquittal and one disagreeing41,2.
WFLA later carried matching WPRI copy saying Clancy appeared Monday and that Sullivan set March 29, 202742,26,27. WFLA said the DA's office did not name the charges, though a prosecutor said a jury would be required, and it quoted Reddington saying the hearing all but confirms a first-degree murder retrial42. Like WPRI and WTNH, the WFLA item used a Dedham dateline and listed Callan as 7 months old42,17,18.
KHON2 carried the same WPRI copy, saying Clancy appeared Monday and that Sullivan set March 29, 202743,17. It said the Plymouth County district attorney's office did not name the charges, though a prosecutor said a jury would be required43,27.
KFOR published matching WPRI copy and also quoted Reddington saying Monday all but confirms a first-degree murder retrial44,42. Both items used a Dedham dateline, as WPRI and WTNH did43,44,17.
A later WHIO item said Sullivan set the new trial for March 29 and that the Plymouth County district attorney's office did not say what charges Clancy would face45. Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Sprague said the case would require a jury, which Reddington treated as an indirect comment that first-degree murder indictments would proceed45,20. WHIO said most of Monday's hearing was spent debating a start date, with prosecutors citing spring conflicts45,35.
Anchorage Daily News and KXAN carried the AP account of the Monday hearing, including Sprague’s statement that prosecutors were ready to pick a jury-trial date and Sullivan’s March 29 setting over a May request46,47.
ABC News Australia carried Associated Press copy saying Sullivan set a March 29, 2027, retrial after prosecutors sought May, with attorneys due back Dec. 30 on logistics, security and media arrangements (AP, via ABC News Australia)48.
The Philadelphia Inquirer later Monday said Sullivan scheduled Clancy's retrial for late March after prosecutors signaled they intend, at least for now, to prosecute again on first-degree murder charges49. The Inquirer said Cruz has not indicated publicly whether the same charges will be used, that Sprague told the judge prosecutors were ready to pick a jury trial date, and that Reddington treated a required jury as an indirect comment that first-degree murder indictments would proceed49. Prosecutors sought a May date, citing scheduling conflicts, and Sullivan set March 29, the Inquirer said49.
CNA later carried the Associated Press account of Sullivan setting a March 29 retrial after prosecutors said they were ready to pick a jury date, with Reddington treating that as an indication first-degree murder charges would continue50.
Sources
- WCVBKey hearing could determine whether Lindsay Clancy faces retrial
- WFLALindsay Clancy to appear in court for pivotal hearing
- WMURKey hearing could determine whether Lindsay Clancy faces retrial
- ReutersLindsay Clancy returns to court as potential murder retrial looms
- (AP, via WSVN 7)Judge sets March retrial for Massachusetts mother accused of killing her 3 childrenAlso (AP, via ClickOrlando), (AP, via ClickOnDetroit), (AP, via The Philadelphia Inquirer), (AP, via Local 10), (AP, via KSAT), (AP, via Stuff), (AP, via Anchorage Daily News), (AP, via KXAN), (AP, via ABC News Australia), (AP, via The Philadelphia Inquirer), (AP, via CNA)
ABC11ABC30ABC7 Los Angeles+31 moreHide
- ABC11Lindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- ABC30Lindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- ABC7 Los AngelesLindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- ABC7 News Bay AreaLindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- ABC7 ChicagoLindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- ABC7 New YorkLindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- 6abcLindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- ABC13 HoustonLindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
- CBS NewsWatch Live: Lindsay Clancy hearing on possible retrial and on what charges
- New York TimesJudge Could Set New Trial Date for Lindsay Clancy
- The Boston GlobeLindsay Clancy due in court as prosecutors weigh whether to retry her on first-degree murder in deaths of her children
- Boston.comLivestream: Lindsay Clancy may get a new trial date in hearing on next steps
- WPRI 12Judge expected to set tentative date for Lindsay Clancy trial
- WTNH News 8Judge expected to set tentative date for Lindsay Clancy trial
- BBCUS woman Lindsay Clancy to face retrial next year for deaths of her three children
- WMURMassachusetts prosecutors retrying Lindsay Clancy in deaths of her 3 children
- RTE NewsLindsay Clancy to face retrial over killing of children
- ABC NewsLindsay Clancy gets new trial date
- KIRO 7Lindsay Clancy faces retrial for first-degree murder starting March 29
- WHIOLindsay Clancy faces retrial for first-degree murder starting March 29
- WPXILindsay Clancy faces retrial for first-degree murder starting March 29
- KRQEJudge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- WGNJudge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- FOX 8 ClevelandJudge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- KSLLindsay Clancy's retrial scheduled for March 2027
- WOWK 13Judge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- NPRLindsay Clancy to face a new trial in spring of 2027 over children's killing
- APJudge sets March retrial for Massachusetts mother accused of killing her 3 children
- SCMPUS judge sets March retrial for Lindsay Clancy, accused of killing her 3 children
- The GuardianJudge sets Lindsay Clancy retrial for March in killings of her three children
- WFLAJudge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- KHON2Judge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- KFORJudge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
- WHIOLindsay Clancy gets new trial date
How it’s being reported
21 versions from 16 sources+10 more
Key hearing could determine whether Lindsay Clancy faces retrial
Whether prosecutors will seek a second trial after last week's denied motions.
Preview of a Monday Plymouth hearing after a mistrial; prosecutors had not committed to retrying Clancy.
Leaves out Outcome of Monday's hearing, which had not yet been reported in the piece we read.
Also from Hearst Television: WMUR
Lindsay Clancy to appear in court for pivotal hearing
First-degree murder charges and the insanity defense versus a prosecution claim of premeditation.
NewsNation copy via WFLA: Monday hearing where prosecutors could say whether they will retry Clancy after a mistrial.
Leaves out Judge Sullivan's name, last week's gag-order ruling, and the hearing outcome.
Lindsay Clancy returns to court as potential murder retrial looms
Gives this outlet’s account of the story.
Lindsay Clancy returns to court for a hearing to determine details of future trial
A possible retrial calendar, lesser charges versus first-degree murder, and last week's double-jeopardy ruling.
ABC News item via ABC11: prosecutors were set Monday to say if, when and how they would retry Clancy; Sullivan had floated a March trial date.
Leaves out Monday hearing outcome; children's ages in the ABC11 copy we read.
Same copy also at ABC affiliates: ABC30 · ABC7 Los Angeles · ABC7 News Bay Area · ABC7 Chicago · ABC7 New York · 6abc · ABC13 Houston
Watch Live: Lindsay Clancy hearing on possible retrial and on what charges
Whether prosecutors would retry first-degree murder or a lesser charge, and a possible plea if charges are reduced.
CBS said Clancy was due Monday in Plymouth Superior Court and that prosecutors were expected to say how they would proceed after a Sept. 4 mistrial.
Leaves out The hearing outcome; Sullivan's March trial comment reported by ABC11.
Judge Could Set New Trial Date for Lindsay Clancy
Gives this outlet’s account of the story.
Lindsay Clancy due in court as prosecutors weigh whether to retry her on first-degree murder in deaths of her children
Charge level for any retrial, the insanity defense, and Clancy's detention at Tewksbury Hospital.
Globe preview of a 10 a.m. Monday Plymouth Superior Court hearing; prosecutors may say whether they will retry first-degree murder or lesser charges after a September mistrial.
Leaves out Monday hearing outcome; Sullivan's March calendar comment reported by ABC11.
Livestream: Lindsay Clancy may get a new trial date in hearing on next steps
Charge-level uncertainty, named holdout juror, and a possible SJC appeal.
com preview of Monday's Plymouth hearing; Reddington said the next step was for District Attorney Tim Cruz.— Boston.com
Boston.com preview of Monday's Plymouth hearing; Reddington said the next step was for District Attorney Tim Cruz.
Leaves out Monday hearing outcome.
Judge expected to set tentative date for Lindsay Clancy trial
Gives this outlet’s account of the story.
Nexstar preview saying prosecutors still plan a retrial and that Sullivan last week denied a dismissal after the September mistrial.
Leaves out Monday hearing outcome; names Plymouth versus the Dedham dateline in the WPRI copy.
Also from Nexstar: WTNH News 8
US woman Lindsay Clancy to face retrial next year for deaths of her three children
The retrial date and that prosecutors did not explicitly say what charges Clancy would face.
BBC said a judge set a second trial for March 29, 2027; prosecutors wanted a jury trial and did not explicitly name the charges. BBC News
Leaves out Reddington's full remark on reading between the lines, reported by WMUR.
Massachusetts prosecutors retrying Lindsay Clancy in deaths of her 3 children
Leads with a figure in the headline.
Hearst/WMUR said prosecutors announced a second trial Monday and the court set March 29 for the start of jury selection.
Leaves out BBC's March 29, 2027 trial-date wording versus jury selection.
Lindsay Clancy to face retrial over killing of children
The March 29 date, first-degree murder exposure and undisputed facts of the killings as RTE described them.
RTE said Sullivan set a second trial for March 29 after a deadlock; it recapped the 2023 Duxbury deaths and the insanity defense.
Leaves out Prosecutors' jury-trial remark and Reddington's charge-level inference reported by BBC and WMUR.
Lindsay Clancy gets new trial date
Cruz's Nov. 2 plan to talk more Nov. 16 and Sullivan's earlier March comment.
Desk listed an updated ABC News headline; the page we read was still a pre-hearing preview of Monday's Plymouth session, not the March date.
Leaves out The hearing outcome reported by BBC, WMUR and RTE; we could not read a post-hearing ABC rewrite.
Lindsay Clancy faces retrial for first-degree murder starting March 29
First-degree murder retrial date and later calendar dates
Cox Media Group copy via KIRO said a judge set a first-degree murder retrial for March 29, with a Dec. 30 status hearing and a Feb. 18 final pretrial.
Leaves out Plymouth courthouse name; explicit jury-selection wording used by WMUR
Judge sets retrial date for Lindsay Clancy
Gives this outlet’s account of the story.
KHON2 carried WPRI copy: Sullivan set March 29, 2027; DA's office did not name charges; a prosecutor said a jury would be required.
Leaves out Reddington's remark that the hearing all but confirms first-degree murder, which KFOR included.
Also from Nexstar: KRQE · WGN · FOX 8 Cleveland · WOWK 13 · WFLA · KFOR
Judge sets March retrial for Massachusetts mother accused of killing her 3 children
Leads with a figure in the headline.
Same copy also at: (AP, via WSVN 7) · (AP, via ClickOrlando) · (AP, via ClickOnDetroit) · (AP, via The Philadelphia Inquirer) · (AP, via Local 10) · (AP, via KSAT) · (AP, via Stuff) · (AP, via Anchorage Daily News) · (AP, via KXAN) · (AP, via ABC News Australia) · (AP, via The Philadelphia Inquirer) · (AP, via CNA)
Lindsay Clancy's retrial scheduled for March 2027
March 29 start, pretrial dates, and a jury-trial remark as a charge-level signal.
KSL said a second trial is set to begin March 29, 2027, with pretrial hearings Dec. 30 and Feb. 18, 2027; it treated a prosecutor's jury-trial remark as a signal of first-degree murder.
Leaves out AP's account that prosecutors sought May and Sullivan set March over objections.
Lindsay Clancy to face a new trial in spring of 2027 over children's killing
Leads with a figure in the headline.
US judge sets March retrial for Lindsay Clancy, accused of killing her 3 children
Leads with a figure in the headline.
Desk listed an SCMP item; the page we retrieved returned an HTTP error so no SCMP facts are used.
Leaves out All body text; WhatsNewPaper could not read the article.
Judge sets Lindsay Clancy retrial for March in killings of her three children
Gives this outlet’s account of the story.
Lindsay Clancy gets new trial date
The March 29 date, unnamed charges and courtroom debate over scheduling.
WHIO said Sullivan set March 29; the DA's office did not name charges; Sprague said a jury was required, which Reddington treated as a first-degree signal.
Leaves out The AP account that prosecutors sought May and Sullivan set March over objections.