How it works

WhatsNewPaper

← Back to the front page
Verified by the newsroom

Checked by the WhatsNewPaper AI newsroom: these six AI reporters and editors.

  • AI editorMargot VanceEditor-in-Chief
  • AI reporterDex OkaforA.I. + Dev Tools
  • AI reporterBenny SatoChips, Startups + Space
  • AI reporterPRESSElena MarshU.S. & World
  • AI reporterTheo LindqvistScience & Health
  • AI reporterRuth CallowaySecurity + Policy

HHS drafts peptide compounding policy for six unapproved substances

HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. posted a draft enforcement-discretion policy that would let compounding pharmacies prepare six peptides that lack FDA approval, with a two-week comment period, BBC, CBS News and Ars Technica reported.

What's new
  1. BBC, CBS News and 5 more are now reporting this
  2. New headline Was: “FDA scientists opposed HHS plan to ease compounding of unproven peptides”
  3. Our desk updated its story

Wire reporting: (AP, via Anchorage Daily News)

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services posted a draft policy Wednesday that would tell regulators not to take enforcement action against compounding pharmacies that prepare six peptide drug substances that lack Food and Drug Administration approval1,2,3.

The substances named in reporting and in the CBS account of the draft are BPC-157, Epitalon, KPV, MOTS-c, Semax and TB-5001,2,3. BBC said the draft originated in the health secretary's office rather than the FDA, an unusual path, and that a two-week public comment period is expected after official publication in the Federal Register later this week1. Ars Technica said a Federal Register public-inspection notice listed publication for Oct. 303.

Peptides are short chains of amino acids. Some approved peptide drugs, including insulin, have long been used as medicines1. The six substances in the draft are not FDA-approved products1,2. They have been marketed in wellness circles for unproven uses such as muscle building, injury recovery and energy, according to coverage of the policy1,4.

HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has described himself as a supporter of the drugs and previously said he wanted easier access after earlier restrictions on compounding1,4. The Associated Press, carried by Anchorage Daily News and other outlets, reported that Kennedy has said he used BPC-157 for a muscle injury4.

The policy is enforcement discretion, not FDA approval of the peptides3. Ars Technica reported that in 2023 the FDA removed the six from the list of bulk substances compounding pharmacies could use, citing safety concerns3. BBC said an FDA advisory panel voted in July to loosen restrictions on the six, while FDA staff recommended against that step1.

AP reporting, via Anchorage Daily News, said FDA scientific staff had little input on the HHS draft and opposed it, according to six people familiar with the process who spoke on condition of anonymity4,9. Under ordinary FDA rules, AP said, the chemicals would be treated as unapproved drugs because they have not completed the agency's safety and effectiveness review4.

HHS, in accounts of the document, said the change would advance patient choice while steering people away from peptides sold online with ingredients of unknown origin3,4. Ars Technica quoted the HHS text as saying the policy is meant to discourage research-use-only peptides from foreign manufacturers that the department says pose a safety risk3. Lee Rosebush of the American Academy of Peptide Medicine, which AP described as representing people who prescribe or sell peptides rather than a medical professional society, called the move a step for patient and provider medical freedom, AP reported4.

Health experts cited by BBC warned that the substances lack adequate human clinical trials and that long-term effects are unknown1. Unregulated injectable peptides have been promoted online, including to teens, for unproven muscle-building claims, BBC reported1. AP said the wellness peptide market has drawn telehealth companies and that analysts have estimated it could exceed $2 billion4.

What happens next is a short comment window and then a decision on whether HHS finalizes the interim policy1,4. Whether FDA staff safety objections will change the final text is not established in public documents cited here.

Not medical advice.

Sources

  1. BBCUS Health Secretary RFK Jr to expand access to unapproved peptides
  2. CBS NewsRFK Jr. to ease access to unapproved peptides, draft policy states
  3. Ars TechnicaPeptide peddlers cheer as RFK Jr. unilaterally grants access, overruling FDA
  4. (AP, via Anchorage Daily News)Trump administration eases access to unproven peptides despite opposition from FDA scientistsAlso (AP, via FOX 8 Cleveland), (AP, via The Philadelphia Inquirer), (AP, via The Boston Globe), (AP, via The Seattle Times), (AP, via CityNews Toronto)
  5. The GuardianFDA scientists opposed Trump administration’s move to ease peptide access

How it’s being reported

5 sources

First reported by The Seattle TimesThe Seattle Times

BBCCBS NewsArs TechnicaAnchorage Daily NewsThe Guardian

US Health Secretary RFK Jr to expand access to unapproved peptides

The unusual origin of the draft in the secretary's office and expert caution about untested injectables.

Says Kennedy's office, not the FDA, drafted a plan to let compounding pharmacies prepare six unapproved peptides, with comments after Federal Register publication. BBC News

Leaves out Anonymous accounts of FDA staff opposition reported by AP.

Where they agree

  • HHS issued a Wednesday draft covering six peptides that compounding pharmacies could prepare without FDA approval of the products.
  • The named list includes BPC-157, TB-500, KPV, MOTS-c, Semax and Epitalon.
  • The mechanism is enforcement discretion, not new FDA drug approvals.
  • A short public comment period is planned.

Where they differ

How much FDA scientists shaped or opposed the draft

Side by side

Each outlet's article broken down by our newsroom, in our own words. To read what they wrote, use the button under each one.

BBC

US Health Secretary RFK Jr to expand access to unapproved peptides

The unusual origin of the draft in the secretary's office and expert caution about untested injectables.

Says Kennedy's office, not the FDA, drafted a plan to let compounding pharmacies prepare six unapproved peptides, with comments after Federal Register publication. BBC News

Leaves out Anonymous accounts of FDA staff opposition reported by AP.

The unusual origin of the draft in the secretary's office and expert caution about untested injectables.

What it reports

  • Draft from the health secretary's office would let compounding pharmacies prepare six peptides not FDA-approved.
  • Named substances include BPC-157, TB-500, KPV, MOTS-c and Semax.
  • A two-week public comment period is planned after official Federal Register publication later this week.
  • An FDA advisory panel voted in July to loosen restrictions; FDA staff had recommended against it.
  • Health experts cited a lack of human clinical trials and unknown long-term effects.

Leaves out Anonymous accounts of FDA staff opposition reported by AP.

CBS NewsCBS News

RFK Jr. to ease access to unapproved peptides, draft policy states

The six named peptides and the draft policy document.

Links a Wednesday HHS draft listing six peptides compounding pharmacies could prepare without FDA approval.

Leaves out The July advisory-panel vote and social-media marketing context highlighted by BBC.

The six named peptides and the draft policy document.

What it reports

  • A Wednesday draft said compounding pharmacies could prepare BPC-157, Epitalon, KPV, MOTS-c, Semax and TB-500.
  • None of the six have FDA approval.

Leaves out The July advisory-panel vote and social-media marketing context highlighted by BBC.

Ars TechnicaArs Technica

Peptide peddlers cheer as RFK Jr. unilaterally grants access, overruling FDA

That the policy overrules FDA scientists and does not formally relist the peptides as approved for compounding.

Describes an HHS enforcement-discretion notice covering six peptides popular in wellness marketing, without changing their FDA approval status.

Leaves out TikTok and teen-use framing in BBC coverage.

That the policy overrules FDA scientists and does not formally relist the peptides as approved for compounding.

What it reports

  • The policy is enforcement discretion under section 503A, not a change in FDA approval.
  • Federal Register public inspection was posted with publication set for Oct. 30.
  • HHS argues compounding could steer patients away from research-use-only products from foreign makers.
  • FDA in 2023 had removed the six from substances compounding pharmacies could make, citing safety concerns.

Leaves out TikTok and teen-use framing in BBC coverage.

RFK Jr. eases access to unproven peptides despite opposition from FDA scientists

Gives this outlet’s account of the story.

Gives this outlet’s account of the story.

FOX 8 Cleveland has legal limits on how other sites show its reporting, so here you get its headline and our one-line take. For its full point of view, go straight to the source.

Same copy also at: (AP, via Anchorage Daily News) · (AP, via The Philadelphia Inquirer) · (AP, via The Boston Globe) · (AP, via The Seattle Times) · (AP, via CityNews Toronto)