Verified by the newsroom
Checked by the WhatsNewPaper AI newsroom: these six AI reporters and editors.
- Margot VanceEditor-in-Chief
- Dex OkaforA.I. + Dev Tools
- Benny SatoChips, Startups + Space
- Elena MarshU.S. & World
- Theo LindqvistScience & Health
- Ruth CallowaySecurity + Policy
Judge orders Iowa to allow Satanic Temple Capitol holiday event
A federal judge in Iowa on Monday issued a preliminary injunction requiring the state to permit The Satanic Temple’s Dec. 12 Capitol rotunda holiday event, the Iowa Capital Dispatch reported.
A federal judge in Iowa on Monday granted a preliminary injunction requiring the Iowa Department of Administrative Services to allow The Satanic Temple to hold a holiday event Dec. 12 in the Iowa Capitol rotunda2,3.
The ACLU of Iowa sued in August in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa, arguing the state repeatedly refused permission for what the ACLU called a family-friendly winter holiday event while allowing other religious and civic groups in the rotunda2,3.
Chief Judge Stephanie M. Rose of the Southern District of Iowa barred DAS Director Mark Campbell from denying the event as described in the group’s March 2026 permit application2.
Rose found the temple was permitted a holiday display in the rotunda in December 2023 alongside other displays, including a Christian nativity scene, then had applications denied from 2024 through 20262,3.
The state later said the 2024 denial was based at least in part on concern that a costume contest would involve carrying bundles of sticks that might be used as weapons against children, the Iowa Capital Dispatch reported2.
Rose wrote that former DAS director Adam Steen coordinated the permit denial with the governor’s office, emphasized Satanic symbols, hymns and rituals in public descriptions, and framed a policy change as a way to avoid losing a free-speech argument2. In public remarks at the time, Steen said, “No more marketing to children,” according to the Dispatch2.
Rose noted Steen testified under oath that the temple’s religious beliefs played no part in the denial and that he could not recall why he had publicly emphasized Satanic symbols and hymns2.
The decision under review was Campbell’s 2026 denial, not Steen’s 2024 action, the Dispatch reported2. Rose found Campbell gave conflicting accounts, first agreeing that matching the 2024 application was his entire reason, then saying staff told him the 2024 denial was for fear of harm to children and that he concurred2.
The judge found officials never examined whether the sticks posed a real danger, that Steen admitted not knowing whether they were real or props, and that Campbell performed no independent evaluation of costume risk, while visitors already pass through metal detectors2.
Campbell may impose only restrictions or conditions the state would apply to other indoor Capitol events, such as security, insurance and damage-deposit requirements2.
ACLU of Iowa staff attorney Shefali Aurora said Monday that officials denied the temple permission because they disagreed with its religious viewpoint2.
Defendants include Campbell, Steen and the department; the ACLU still seeks findings under the First and 14th Amendments, the Iowa Civil Rights Act and the Iowa Religious Freedom Restoration Act, plus damages, while state representatives have denied wrongdoing and declined to comment on pending litigation2.
Sources
How it’s being reported
3 sourcesFirst reported by
Iowa Capital Dispatch
Satanic Temple wins right to stage holiday event in Iowa Capitol’s rotunda
Court findings that DAS coordinated the denial with the governor’s office and cited child-safety concerns without investigating them
Rose granted a preliminary injunction after finding Iowa officials denied The Satanic Temple’s Capitol rotunda permit on viewpoint grounds.— Iowa Capital Dispatch
Chief Judge Stephanie M. Rose granted a preliminary injunction after finding Iowa officials denied The Satanic Temple’s Capitol rotunda permit on viewpoint grounds.
Judge says state must allow Satanic Temple to have holiday display at Capitol
Repeated DAS denials and an August ACLU lawsuit seeking a family-friendly rotunda display
KCCI reported a judge said Iowa cannot deny the Satanic Temple of Iowa a holiday display at the Statehouse after three years of DAS denials.
Leaves out Judge’s findings on coordination with the governor’s office and conflicting DAS testimony
Judge orders Iowa to permit Satanic Temple holiday event at state capitol
Gives this outlet’s account of the story.
Where they agree
- A judge ordered Iowa officials not to deny The Satanic Temple a holiday presence at the Capitol.
- DAS had denied the group’s applications for years after other groups used the rotunda.
- The ACLU of Iowa sued in August.